Prince Harry on Parade as Officer Cadet Wales at Sandhurst in 2005.

Prince Harry returned to active service in Afghanistan this morning. In contrast to his previous overseas tour of duty, as an Forward Air Controller in Helmand Province in 2008, the media has been informed of the Prince’s activities. In his new role as a co-pilot gunner of an Apache helicopter, he will not be recognizable to his opponents. Harry’s missions as an Apache pilot will include supporting ground troops under attack from Taliban insurgents and providing an escort for aircraft transporting troops or equipment. The technology in the Apache helicopters may be twenty-first century but Prince Harry’s presence in Afghanistan is part of a royal tradition of military leadership that dates back to the origins of monarchy in the British Isles.

Statue of Alfred the Great in Winchester erected a thousand years after his death

The Saxon Kings of what is now England in the Early Middle Ages were primarily war leaders whose goal was the defence of their kingdoms from Viking invasions. Even Alfred the Great (r. 871-899), famous for his endowments of monasteries and other places of learning was only able to act as a cultural patron after he had successfully defeated King Guthrum of the Danish Vikings in 880 and united the Saxon kingdoms under his rule. Saxon Kings who were unwilling face their responsibilities as war leaders such as Aethelred the Unready (r. 978-1013 and 1014-1016), who preferred to pay tribute to the Danes, lost their legitimacy as monarchs.

The importance of the King as a war leader superseded all other considerations regarding the English royal succession in the early Middle Ages. The Battle of Hastings in 1066 reflected eleventh century attitudes toward kingship as a military vocation. Under modern succession law, neither William, Duke of Normandy nor Harold Godwinson would be considered a suitable heir to King Edward the Confessor. Harold was Edward’s brother-in-law and William was a second cousin born out of wedlock. Edward’s closest living relative, Edgar the Aetheling, however, was only in his early teens in 1066, too young to serve as an effective war leader. William became the first Norman King of England because of his prowess on the battlefield.

The Gatehouse of Battle Abbey, commissioned by William I to celebrate his victory against Harold II at the Battle of Hastings.

The expectation that the King would serve as a military commander also created barriers to female succession. When William I’s youngest son, Henry I died in 1135, his only surviving child, Matilda was unable to travel to Westminster to claim the throne in person because she was pregnant with her youngest son. When her cousin Stephen was acclaimed King, Matilda had to appoint a military leader, her half brother Robert of Gloucester, to defend her rights because she could not take the field on her own behalf. Stephen ultimately ended the conflict by leaving his throne to Matilda’s eldest son, the future Henry II.

Statue of Richard I outside the Houses of Parliament at Westminster

In the High Middle Ages, Kings of England proved their military valour through participation in the Crusades and later, the Wars of the Roses. King Richard I, “The Lionhearted” achieved victories in the Third Crusade (1189-1192) and the future Edward I was wounded by an assassin during the Ninth Crusade (1271-1272). Edward’s injury and the news that he had succeeded to the English throne ended the last period of English royal military service in the Middle East until Prince Harry’s 2008 Tour of Duty. Edward continued his military leadership as King, defeating Llywelyn the Last, Prince of Wales in 1282 and earning a reputation as “The Hammer of the Scots.”

During the Wars of the Roses in the fifteenth century, success on the battlefield once again determined a King’s legitimacy. Richard II and Henry VI lost their thrones because they were unable or unwilling to fight for their thrones while Henry V and Edward IV gained popular acclaim for their prowess on the battlefield. When Henry VII defeated Richard III at the Battle of Bosworth field in 1485, he significantly claimed the throne by right of conquest rather than by his marriage to Richard’s niece, Elizabeth of York.

Portrait of Elizabeth I commemorating the defeat of the Spanish Armada in 1588

Although the ascension of the Tudor dynasty appeared to ensure a more stable line of succession, the fortunes of sixteenth and seventeenth centuries monarchs continued to rise and fall on the battlefield. In 1553, Queen Mary I secured her claim to the throne by raising a military force that successfully challenged the powerful supporters of her cousin, Lady Jane Grey. The circumstances of Mary’s ascension and the defeat of the Spanish Armada in 1588 proved that female rulers could preside over the successful military campaigns that ensured a monarch’s legitimacy. During the War of the Spanish Succession in the early eighteenth century, Queen Anne would receive popular acclaim because of the victories of her appointed general, John Churchill, Duke of Marlborough.

Portrait of King George II at the Battle of Dettingen in 1743.

In the seventeenth century, Charles I would lose his throne when he was defeated during the English Civil Wars of the 1640s and both Charles II and William III would assemble invading forces in an attempt to secure their succession to the English and Scottish thrones from continental Europe. The last British monarch to personally lead his troops into battle was King George II, who participated in the Battle of Dettingen in the War of the Austrian Succession in 1743, an event that inspired George Frederick Handel’s Te Deum.

The tradition of royal military service in the British Isles continued long after the reign of George II. While the monarch and his direct heirs no longer directly participated in military engagements, younger sons within the royal family often pursued careers in the armed forces. Queen Victoria’s third son, Prince Arthur, Duke of Connaught served as a Lieutenant for forty years in various parts of the British Empire. As second sons, both King George V and King George VI had naval careers before ascending to the throne. Prince Harry’s uncle, Prince Andrew served as a Sea King helicopter co-pliot during the Falklands War in 1982-1893. Prince Harry’s second tour of duty in Afghanistan is part of a centuries long tradition of royal military service that shaped the course of England’s thousand year old monarchy.

Prince Harry delivering a speech at the official press launch of Walking with the Wounded in March, 2010

Prince Harry visited Washington D.C. this week to receive the Distinguished Humanitarian Leadership Award, presented by former Secretary of State Colin Powell during the Atlantic Council 2012 Annual Awards Dinner on May 7, 2012. The Prince was recognized for the work that he and his older brother, the Duke of Cambridge, have undertaken as patrons of charities that support injured British and American servicemen and women. These organizations include Walking with the Wounded, a British charity that retrains veterans for new careers, and Help for Heroes, which helps wounded members of the armed forces.

Prince Harry received an enthusiastic welcome from his American admirers. Powell joked at the awards dinner “We have a record number of young, single women attending this year.” The Associated Press noted that “a bevy of young female admirers” were gathered outside the Ritz-Carleton hotel where the gala took place. Although the United States severed political ties with the British monarchy during the American Revolutionary War of the late eighteenth century, the country has always given a warm welcome to traveling Princes.

Prince Albert Edward, the future King Edward VII visiting Niagara Falls in 1860.

The theme of young, unmarried Princes being pursued by admiring American women has been constant in the popular press since the mid nineteenth century. Journalists hoped to be able to report a Cinderella story if a romance took place between a visiting prince and an American woman. When Prince Albert Edward, the nineteen year old eldest son of Queen Victoria visited the United States for a month in 1860, following a successful tour of British North America, the New York Herald urged every young American woman to “put on her most bewitching smile” for “to catch a prince is no common achievement.” When the Herald learned that the Prince enjoyed dancing, it urged its female readers to “be prepared, armed at all points, [to] show the Prince of Wales that they can dance better than the damsels of the British Provinces” encouraging some friendly competition with the Prince’s Canadian admirers. For more accounts of Prince Albert Edward and his American admirers in the press, see Ian Radforth, Royal Spectacle: The 1860 Visit of the Prince of Wales to Canada and the United States, p. 330-335.

The American press was equally interested twenty years later when Albert Edward’s younger brother, Prince Leopold traveled to Niagara Falls and Chicago with his sister Princess Louise, the wife of the Governor General of Canada, in 1880. The press dubbed the siblings “Vic’s Chicks” and took a close interest in their travels, and Leopold’s marriage prospects. Neither Queen Victoria nor Louise’s husband, Lord Lorne, were impressed by the coverage of the tour by American journalists. Lorne wrote to his father indignantly, “the vulgarity of the Yankee press about them surpasses belief.” Louise returned to the United Kingdom with Leopold at the end of their travels.

General George Custer and Grand Duke Alexei in Topeka after their buffalo hunt.

The press coverage of the 1871 American tour by Grand Duke Alexei Alexandrovich, fourth son of Emperor Alexander II of Russia demonstrated that interest in royalty in the United States extended to members of the other ruling houses of Europe. When the Grand Duke’s ship, Svetlana, sailed into New York harbour, the Imperial visitor received a reception that included a parade down Broadway with marching bands and military regiments, and the bells of local churches chiming “God Save the Tsar.” According to Russian historian Zoia Belyakova in The Grand Dukes, “Public curiosity was intense. The myth of Alexis the lady-killer spread. Young women were most interested in his Imperial Highness . . . In Cleveland and Detroit he was literally besieged by admiring young women.” The Grand Duke enjoyed his travels, which included a buffalo hunt with Lieutenant Custer and Buffalo Bill Cody, and was pleasantly surprised by the warmth of his welcome in a democratic republic.

The warm welcome that Prince Harry  received this week in Washington D.C. is similar to the accolades received by Prince Albert Edward, Prince Leopold and Grand Duke Alexei. The American press is always interested in a traveling European Prince and the potential for a Cinderella story involving a heroine from the United States.